Contents
What is Under-Positioning and Over-Positioning?
Under-positioning and over-positioning refer to two distinct but equally problematic positioning strategies that can undermine a product’s success in the market. Both terms highlight issues with how a brand or product is perceived by its target market and often stem from a misalignment between the intended and actual positioning communicated to consumers.
Under-Positioning
Under-positioning occurs when a firm fails to communicate a clear and distinct positioning for a product. This lack of clarity may result from vague messaging, an unfocused strategy, or an attempt to convey too much information about the product. As a result, consumers struggle to identify what the product represents or how it differs from competitors.
Causes of Under-Positioning:
- Lack of Focus: Trying to emphasize too many features or benefits dilutes the brand’s message, leaving consumers unclear about the product’s unique value.
- Generic Messaging: Positioning that relies on broad or generic claims (e.g., “high quality” or “best value”) fails to establish a meaningful point-of-difference.
- Poor Communication: Inadequate or inconsistent communication across marketing channels can result in a weak perception of the product.
Consequences of Under-Positioning:
- Confused Consumers: The target audience may not understand the product’s benefits or why they should choose it over alternatives.
- Weak Differentiation: The product is perceived as one of many in a crowded market with no unique identity.
- Missed Opportunities: Without a clear point-of-difference, the product may fail to attract its intended target market, limiting its sales potential.
Example of Under-Positioning:
A mid-tier smartphone brand that advertises its product as “affordable, stylish, and powerful” without elaborating on its specific advantages (e.g., longer battery life or better camera quality) may leave consumers unclear about its strengths. This lack of focus can result in the product being overlooked.
Over-Positioning
Over-positioning occurs when a firm focuses too heavily on one or two specific product attributes, leading to a narrow or overly specialized perception of the product. While this strategy may appeal strongly to a small segment of the market, it risks alienating broader audiences who might otherwise consider the product.
Causes of Over-Positioning:
- Excessive Emphasis on a Single Feature: Highlighting one attribute exclusively can overshadow other important benefits or points-of-parity.
- Narrow Targeting: Positioning that appeals only to a niche market can limit broader market appeal.
- Inflexibility: Focusing too narrowly makes it difficult for the brand to adapt its messaging for wider audiences or product extensions.
Consequences of Over-Positioning:
- Perceived Specialization: The product may be seen as catering only to a small or niche audience, limiting its market reach and growth potential.
- Missed Opportunities for Cross-Segments: Broader customer segments may overlook the product because they don’t see it as relevant to their needs.
- Reduced Market Share: Over-positioning restricts the product’s potential appeal, confining it to a narrow market segment.
Example of Over-Positioning:
A luxury car brand that markets itself solely as “the car for CEOs” may alienate affluent professionals who aspire to own a luxury vehicle but don’t identify as executives. By overemphasizing exclusivity, the brand risks losing customers who feel excluded.
Common Outcomes and Solutions
Whether a product is under-positioned or over-positioned, the end result is the same: limited sales and market potential. In the case of under-positioning, consumers fail to see the product’s relevance or differentiation, while over-positioning narrows the market too much, excluding potential buyers.
Solution:
- Balanced Positioning Strategy: A well-constructed positioning strategy should incorporate a mix of points-of-parity (attributes that establish the product’s legitimacy within its category) and points-of-difference (attributes that make it stand out). This balance ensures the product is seen as both relevant and distinctive.
- Market Research: Understanding the target market’s needs and preferences is critical to developing a positioning strategy that resonates with a broad yet defined audience.
- Consistent Communication: Clear and consistent messaging across all marketing channels ensures that consumers accurately perceive the product’s intended positioning.
In summary, effective positioning lies in striking a balance—avoiding the pitfalls of vagueness or overspecialization—to ensure the product appeals to its target market while maintaining a distinct identity.
Examples of Under-Positioning and Over-Positioning
Under-Positioning Examples
- Mid-Tier Laptop Brand
- Scenario: A laptop brand advertises its product as “sleek, affordable, and high-performance” without highlighting specific features like battery life, processing power, or unique design elements.
- Outcome: Consumers perceive it as generic and interchangeable with other laptops in the same price range, leading to weak brand differentiation.
- A Restaurant Chain
- Scenario: A restaurant claims to serve “delicious, fresh food,” but fails to specify its unique cuisine, ingredients, or dining experience.
- Outcome: Without a clear identity (e.g., health-focused, premium dining, or family-friendly), the chain struggles to stand out in a competitive market.
- Smartphone App
- Scenario: An app promotes itself as a “one-stop productivity tool” but doesn’t clarify its core functionality (e.g., task management, scheduling, or team collaboration).
- Outcome: Potential users don’t see how the app fits their specific needs, resulting in low adoption rates.
Over-Positioning Examples
- Luxury Watch Brand
- Scenario: A watch brand markets itself exclusively as “the timepiece for CEOs,” emphasizing exclusivity and high status.
- Outcome: While the brand may appeal to wealthy executives, it alienates affluent customers who aspire to own a luxury watch but don’t identify as CEOs.
- Organic Snack Company
- Scenario: A snack company heavily promotes its “100% organic and sustainable” production process while neglecting to emphasize taste, convenience, or affordability.
- Outcome: The product is perceived as niche and appealing only to environmentally conscious consumers, limiting broader market appeal.
- Professional Camera Brand
- Scenario: A camera brand markets its product solely to professional photographers, focusing on advanced features and high-end specifications.
- Outcome: Casual photography enthusiasts feel excluded, even if the camera could meet their needs, reducing potential sales.
Balanced Positioning Examples
- Tesla
- Scenario: Tesla markets its vehicles as innovative (electric and autonomous features) while also emphasizing luxury, performance, and environmental benefits.
- Outcome: Tesla appeals to multiple segments—tech enthusiasts, eco-conscious consumers, and luxury car buyers—creating broad market appeal without diluting its identity.
- Apple iPhone
- Scenario: Apple positions the iPhone as a premium product with superior design and performance while also offering diverse features that appeal to various user needs (e.g., camera quality, user experience, app ecosystem).
- Outcome: The iPhone captures both high-end users and aspirational buyers seeking a premium yet versatile device.
- Starbucks
- Scenario: Starbucks promotes its coffee as high-quality and ethically sourced while also emphasizing the personalized experience (e.g., custom drinks, welcoming stores).
- Outcome: The brand balances product quality with customer experience, appealing to both casual coffee drinkers and connoisseurs.